Opinion | Trump Told a Black Woman She Can't See Dirt. That's Racism 101.

The south facade of the White House in Washington, D.C.
The White House, south facade. Trump told NBC's Yamiche Alcindor the building is "flawless" before saying she doesn't "see dirt." Photo: Matt H. Wade via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

OPINION · By Joseph J. Jackson | ST. PETERSBURG (Nov. 16, 2026)

No more "is it or isn't it." He said it out loud, on camera, to her face. Calling it anything else is gaslighting.

Short version

  • NBC's Yamiche Alcindor asked Trump about the air travel collapse. He told her: "I know you don't see dirt... you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come."

  • It's the second time this year he's used "dirt" on a Black woman reporter. In May it was ABC's Rachel Scott.

  • This is racism. Not "racially tinged." Not "controversial." Racism.

She asked about airports. He went after where she comes from.

Monday morning on the South Lawn, Yamiche Alcindor did her job. She asked the President of the United States why he was pouring his attention into ballrooms and reflecting pools while the country's air travel system fell apart under Republican control.

A fair question. A necessary one.

Trump answered by telling her to listen. Then this: "I know you don't see dirt. But if you take a look at the White House, you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come." (Full transcript)

Not "your network." Not "Washington." From where you come. Said by a white man to a Black woman, with the whole press corps watching.

This is the oldest racist script in America.

Dirty. Broken windows. Doesn't notice filth because she's used to it. "Where you come from."

Black Americans have been hearing that script for 150 years. It was used to justify redlining. It was used to justify bulldozing Black neighborhoods for highways. It was used to justify "broken windows" policing that filled jails with Black men for jumping turnstiles. Trump didn't stumble into those words. He's been running that play his whole life.

He did it in May, too. Almost word for word.

When ABC's Rachel Scott asked why he was fixing monuments while gas prices climbed, Trump told her: "You can understand dirt maybe better than I can." Then he called her "a horror show." (Fox News) The National Association of Black Journalists called his use of "dirt" against a Black woman "especially disturbing." (theGrio)

He's told Alcindor herself she's "second-rate." (Atlanta Black Star) He called Ebony McMorris "obnoxious." (Atlanta Black Star) He called Akayla Gardner a "dumb person." (theGrio)

Once is a slip. Twice, with the same word, aimed at the same kind of woman, is a policy.

Denying it is gaslighting.

I lived through the first term. Every single week, the same routine. He'd say something racist. The networks would call it "racially charged." His people would say we were hysterical. Those of us who called it what it was got told we were the problem.

That was gaslighting then. It's gaslighting now.

We're done with it. Done softening the word so the people who said it feel comfortable. Done waiting for "both sides" to weigh in on whether a Black woman's dignity counts. If you hear "I know you don't see dirt, from where you come" and your first move is to defend him, you've told us exactly where you stand.

The most openly racist president since the Civil War.

I've read this man's record for ten years. Here's my verdict: Donald Trump is the most openly racist president since the Civil War. Yes, I'm counting Woodrow Wilson. Wilson resegregated the federal workforce and screened The Birth of a Nation in the White House. He did real, lasting damage. But Wilson's generation dressed its racism up in polite language.

Trump doesn't bother with the costume. He says it on camera, to a Black woman's face, and dares the country to do something about it.

Their excuse doesn't hold.

His defenders will say he insults every reporter, that he told a white Bloomberg reporter "quiet, piggy," that "where you come from" meant the media. (Wikipedia)

He does insult everyone. That's the point. He has an insult for every reporter, and he picks the insult to fit the target. White men get "fake news." White women get "piggy." Black women get "dirt."

That's not equal-opportunity rudeness. That's racism and bigotry with a menu.

Call it what it is. Then vote like you mean it.

Joseph J. Jackson is the founder of Florida Man News Network and author of the four-volume Death of the American Dream. Opinions are his own.

Sources

  • Tommy Christopher, Nov. 16, 2026: full transcript of the departure gaggle.

  • HuffPost, Nov. 16, 2026: "Listen To Me!" Trump erupts at Alcindor.

  • Raw Story, Nov. 16, 2026: the FAA question and Trump's answer.

  • Fox News, May 8, 2026: Trump and ABC's Rachel Scott.

  • theGrio, May 11, 2026: NABJ statement on Rachel Scott.

  • theGrio, May 12, 2026: Akayla Gardner, "You dumb person."

  • Atlanta Black Star, Sept. 8, 2025: Alcindor, "second-rate."

  • Atlanta Black Star, Sept. 22, 2025: Ebony McMorris, "obnoxious."

  • Wikipedia, Donald Trump's conflict with the news media: "Quiet, piggy."

Photo: The White House, south facade. Matt H. Wade, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Previous
Previous

United Airlines and the Big Banks Go Down the Same Afternoon. That's Four Failures in Five Days.

Next
Next

The Daily Recap, Tampa Bay Edition: Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026