Seven Homes and a Fish Store for a Drive-Thru: St. Pete Clears Way for Chick-fil-A Expansion on Fourth Street

A Chick-fil-A restaurant and its drive-thru lane in Lake City, Florida
A Chick-fil-A on U.S. 90 in Lake City, Fla. (not the Fourth Street North location). Photo: Michael Rivera via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped).

By Joseph J. Jackson | ST. PETERSBURG (Nov. 13, 2026)

The Chick-fil-A at 4201 Fourth St. N. is getting bigger. Not the restaurant. The parking lot.

On Nov. 5, St. Petersburg City Council voted 7-1 to approve land-use and zoning changes that let the restaurant expand south onto neighboring property. That property holds a seven-unit apartment building from the 1950s and the Village Shoppes, a seven-bay strip of small businesses facing Fourth Street. Both would be torn down. (St Pete Catalyst, Florida Politics)

The restaurant itself would grow by just 202 square feet. Parking would roughly double, and the drive-thru would get more room so lines stop backing onto Fourth Street. (St Pete Catalyst)

Vice Chair Richie Floyd cast the only no vote.

The board that said no

The city's own advisory board turned it down first. In August, the Community Planning and Preservation Commission voted 4-3 against the plan over the lost homes and businesses. "I am concerned about the loss of residential units and particularly small-scale residential structures in our city that we are actively losing," Commissioner Shannon Nelson said then. (St Pete Catalyst)

The operator appealed. Council overturned the commission.

Who has to move

Seven households live in the apartment building. Some are long-term tenants. One had moved out temporarily after a hurricane and planned to come back. (St Pete Catalyst)

The Village Shoppes include Fourth Street Tackle, which owner Tom Karakorn says has been there 17 years, and Aquatic Galleria, a freshwater aquarium shop co-owned by Anulak Singphiphat and Troy Barton.

Singphiphat told ABC Action News he'd just bought equipment and holiday inventory. "I was planning to stay here," he said. He called the process "an emotional roller coaster" and said he wouldn't have renewed his lease if he'd known. He said moving live animals could be catastrophic for the shop. (ABC Action News)

Another business owner told reporters that just signing a new lease could cost $16,000 to $18,000. (St Pete Catalyst via Yahoo)

The applicant's attorney, Megan Smith, said the team would help residents find housing and help the aquarium find a new spot. No money or written relocation deal was laid out at the hearing. (St Pete Catalyst)

RELATED: Crist Won by 24. Now the Hard Part: The Trop, the Rays and More

The case for it

Operator David Neely has run this Chick-fil-A since 1999. He says the drive-thru line regularly spills onto Fourth Street and creates a safety problem. (Bay News 9) The restaurant employs more than 130 people with about $2.5 million in yearly payroll, and the applicant says the project could add 50 to 75 jobs. The plan removes the Fourth Street driveway and adds sidewalks and landscaping.

City staff said it fits the Fourth Street commercial corridor. Council member Gina Driscoll agreed, but pushed the business community to help the shops being pushed out: "David's business is important, but the fish store is important too." (St Pete Catalyst)

Floyd warned that small commercial expansions like this one eat into neighborhoods a few lots at a time. He compared it to an affordable housing project council rejected in October.

Rev. Andy Oliver of Allendale United Methodist Church put a sign out front supporting the tenants and businesses. He told ABC Action News the community has to stand up for people on the margins. (ABC Action News)

The Pride question

St. Petersburg is home to Florida's biggest Pride celebration. In this city, Chick-fil-A's name carries history.

In 2012, Dan Cathy, then the company's president, publicly opposed same-sex marriage, saying the country was "inviting God's judgement on our nation" by redefining it. (Fortune) The company's charitable arms gave millions to groups LGBTQ advocates called anti-LGBTQ. Fortune reported that in 2017 the Chick-fil-A Foundation gave more than $1.8 million to three of them, years after the company said it would step back. (Fortune, The Advocate)

In November 2019, Chick-fil-A said it would stop giving to the Salvation Army and the Fellowship of Christian Athletes and change how it donates. (GPB/NPR) Dan Cathy, now chairman, has said he regretted dragging the company into the fight but did not change his personal views. (PinkNews)

Last month, CEO Andrew Cathy was asked on NBC's TODAY where the company stands on LGBTQ rights. He said Chick-fil-A is focused on "hospitality" for every customer and did not address the past donations. (PinkNews) The chain now draws fire from both sides: some conservatives say it has "gone woke."

None of that history is about David Neely or his employees. But it's why a vote clearing homes for a Chick-fil-A drive-thru lands differently in St. Pete than it would in most cities. People here remember who stood where.

What's next

The Nov. 5 vote covered land use and zoning only. The site plan still needs more city review before anything comes down. (St Pete Catalyst)

Chick-fil-A has not answered the questions that matter most to the people being moved: how much relocation money, if any, they'll get, and when demolition starts. The company did not respond to repeated requests for comment from ABC Action News. (ABC Action News)

Previous
Previous

DeSantis Wants Amendment 3 Rules by Jan. 1. Florida’s Next Legislative Leaders Want to Wait for Donalds.

Next
Next

Opinion | Put His Name on It. Get Everyone Covered. Fix the Sign Later.