The Hate Is the Product. Here’s the Receipt, and Here’s the Bill.

A frame from FMNN's Part 6 video: 'Is this treason? A new kind of war. Digital. Undeclared. Fought without a formal declaration.'
From the Part 6 video below. Motion illustration by FMNN; figures from sourced reporting; AI-voiced narration.

For five parts we followed the money. Tonight we name what it buys. A fake story about the first Muslim elected to the Senate shows the whole machine running at once, and it shows something else: in November, the machine lost.

By Joseph J. Jackson | TAMPA BAY (Nov. 16, 2026)

Part 6 of 6. The case so far: Part 1: The Price List · Part 2: The Gap · Part 3: Foreign Buyers · Part 4: The Megaphone Owners · Part 5: This Is a War.

The short version

  • The product: Days after the election, a made-up story said Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed "failed" a security clearance. No such check exists. It spread anyway, because it was built to.

  • The machine: Someone pays for the post. No law makes anyone say so. Foreign governments shop in the same market. A handful of owners carry it. And the people paid to watch were sent home.

  • The receipt: $9.7 million from Moscow. $9.1 million from one Democratic-aligned group. Up to $5,000 a post. Zero federal laws requiring a label.

  • The verdict: Almost all of it is legal. That's the scandal.

  • The bill: Four lines of law would put a price tag on every paid political post. Florida can pass them in March.

It took less than a week

Michigan elected Abdul El-Sayed on Nov. 3. He's the first Muslim ever elected to the U.S. Senate. Within days, a post was moving across X, Facebook and Substack saying he had "failed the background check required for classified Senate briefings."

There is no background check. Senators get access with the office. Snopes and Lead Stories both rated the claim false. Lead Stories traced it to accounts it has fact-checked before, run by a creator whose Facebook page lists its category as "Comedian." A Substack reposted it as "BREAKING" and guessed the denial was "likely" over Muslim Brotherhood ties. Big accounts passed it along with a wink.

Here's the tell. All fall, El-Sayed's critics, including Sen. Ted Cruz, warned that senators get classified access automatically, with no clearance at all. After he won, the story flipped to "he was denied." The facts didn't change. The lie did, because the old one stopped selling.

That isn't a rumor. That's a product. And for five parts, we've been walking through the factory that makes it.

The machine, in five moves

1. Somebody places an order. Campaigns, PACs and nonprofits on the left and the right pay creators to post politics as their own opinion. A Democratic-aligned project paid creators up to $8,000 a month. A Republican firm in West Palm Beach collected $6,250 a month each from Byron Donalds' campaign and a PAC backing him. (Part 1: The Price List)

2. Nobody has to tell you. A shampoo ad needs a label. A paid political post doesn't. Congress came within one Senate vote of fixing that in 2010 and hasn't come that close since. The agency that could write the rule has been without enough members to act since May 1, 2025. (Part 2: The Gap)

3. The store is open to anyone. Federal prosecutors say Russian state TV hid $9.7 million behind shell companies and fake invoices to fund American commentators, who say they didn't know and weren't charged. China, Iran and Israel's government have all been tied to campaigns aimed at Americans. (Part 3: Foreign Buyers)

4. A few owners hold the megaphone. One company now owns both Channel 8 and Channel 10 in Tampa Bay; a judge is keeping them apart while eight states sue. One family controls CBS News and CNN. The FCC threw out the cap on TV ownership on a 2–1 vote. (Part 4: The Megaphone Owners)

5. The guards went home. In February 2025, the attorney general disbanded the FBI task force built to catch foreign influence. The State Department's office closed. When Russian-linked fake videos hit Senate candidates this fall, private researchers named them. The government didn't. (Part 5: This Is a War)

That's the factory. Here's what comes off the line.

What the machine makes

It doesn't make arguments. Arguments are slow and they don't pay. It makes fear of your neighbor, and it makes it the same way every time.

  • Springfield, Ohio, 2024. Haitian immigrants were "eating pets." There was never any evidence. It reached more than 67 million people in one presidential debate.

  • Kamala Harris, 2024. "The White House will smell like curry." Not a claim. A racist joke about the daughter of immigrants. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene called it "appalling and extremely racist."

  • Abdul El-Sayed, 2026. A Muslim Brotherhood "plant," then a "failed" clearance. PolitiFact found he was never a member. The check doesn't exist.

Five steps, every time:

  1. Pick the target by who they are. Their religion. Their skin. Their parents' country.

  2. Invent a threat. They're eating your pets. They're spies. They're taking your country.

  3. Move faster than the truth. Millions of views before a mayor, a governor or a fact-checker can answer.

  4. Call the correction censorship.

  5. Collect.

How a lie gets to the White House

Take the pets story apart, because we have the whole chain. It shows every step, and it shows who was standing at the top.

It started with a missing cat. In early September 2024, a Springfield woman posted in a private Facebook group that a neighbor's friend had lost a cat and blamed Haitian neighbors. NewsGuard tracked both women down. Neither had seen anything. The story was fourth-hand by the time it was typed, and both said they had no proof. "It just exploded," the woman who posted it told NBC News. A neo-Nazi group had already marched in Springfield that August over the city's Haitian residents.

Then it got a megaphone. On Sept. 5 a screenshot jumped to X. By Sept. 6, accounts with millions of followers were posting it alongside a video of a woman arrested for killing a cat. That arrest was in Canton, not Springfield, and the woman was a U.S. citizen born in Ohio with no tie to Haiti.

Then a U.S. senator picked it up. On Sept. 9, JD Vance, then Ohio's senator and the Republican nominee for vice president, posted the claim to his 1.9 million followers. That same morning, one of his own staffers called Springfield's city manager, Bryan Heck, and asked point-blank if it was true. "I told him no," Heck told The Wall Street Journal.

Vance didn't take the post down. The next day he wrote that the rumors might "turn out to be false," and in the same breath told his followers to "keep the cat memes flowing." By that afternoon, 159 right-wing influencers and 23 Republican politicians and officials had pushed it, by The Washington Post's count.

Then it went on national television. On Sept. 10, Donald Trump said it on the debate stage.

Then Springfield paid for it. The city took 36 bomb threats in a week. Schools and city buildings closed. Springfield's Republican mayor said he'd told national figures the claims were untrue, and they kept repeating them. When the Journal asked Vance's campaign for evidence, it sent a police report from a woman who thought her cat had been taken. She told the Journal she'd been mistaken, and she apologized to her Haitian neighbors.

Then he said the quiet part. On CNN on Sept. 15, Vance said that if he had to "create stories" to get the media to pay attention to his constituents, that's what he'd do. He said afterward that he meant creating attention, not making things up, and that he was passing along what constituents told him.

Read the timeline again. His own office was told it was false on day one. He kept going.

That man is now the vice president of the United States.

And this fall the same play ran from the top. In October, President Trump called Abdul El-Sayed a "Muslim Brotherhood Member." CBS News reported there is no evidence for that. Vice President Vance went to Michigan and praised the Republican candidate for pressing the same claim. So when a fake "clearance denial" showed up days after the election, it didn't need anyone's help. The White House had already spent a month telling the country what to believe about him.

In 2024 the lie had to climb from a Facebook group to a debate stage. In 2026 it started at the top and worked its way down.

Step five

Step five is the one nobody talks about. So let's talk about it.

Laura Loomer bragged about pushing the Springfield memes and posted the "curry" line. The Washington Post reported on Nov. 7 that private clients paid her to post political messages without telling her followers: four payments totaling more than $60,000, at $3,000 to $5,000 a post, according to two sources. She denies being paid per tweet. She also told the Post: "I'm not going to apologize for monetizing the fact that people fear me."

Read that sentence again. That's not a confession of a crime. It's a business plan.

And the platforms pay it out. X shares ad revenue with creators based on engagement. Outrage gets engagement. Engagement gets paid. Nothing makes people angrier, faster, than being told an outsider is coming for them.

The hate isn't a side effect of this machine. The hate is the product. You were never the customer. You're the inventory. Your anger is what's being sold, and your neighbor is the packaging.

The receipt

This is everything six parts put on the record. Every line is sourced in the part it came from.

  • $9.7 million: what prosecutors say Russia's RT wired to one Tennessee company. One wire's memo said it was for an iPhone.

  • $9.1 million: what one Democratic-aligned group, Way to Win, spent on more than 550 creators in 2024, according to RealClearInvestigations. None of it shows up in federal campaign records.

  • $400,000: what one creator was reportedly paid in California's governor's race. The campaign denied wrongdoing.

  • $3,000 to $5,000: the reported price of one post from one account.

  • About $2.7 billion: what super PACs spent in 2024 alone.

  • 16 million: YouTube views on the videos Moscow's money paid for.

  • 857,000: views a Russian-linked fake video got in 24 hours this October.

  • 36: bomb threats Springfield, Ohio, took in one week over a story about a cat.

  • 16 years: how long Congress has had a disclosure bill sitting in front of it.

  • One: the number of Senate votes it fell short by in 2010.

  • 307: cases backed up at the Federal Election Commission, which can't act on any of them.

  • Zero: federal laws that make a creator tell you a campaign paid for the post.

Both parties are on that receipt. I put them there in Part 1 and I'm leaving them there. But look at who the product gets aimed at: Muslims, Haitians, the children of immigrants. The money comes from every direction. The hate goes in one.

"You can't yell fire in a crowded theater"

Everyone's heard it. It isn't the law. Justice Holmes wrote it in 1919 to uphold jailing a man who handed out flyers against the draft. The Supreme Court replaced that standard in 1969. Today the government can punish speech only in narrow cases: incitement to imminent lawless action, true threats, fraud and defamation.

So most of this is legal, and FMNN isn't asking anyone to make it a crime. A government that decides which lies are illegal will soon decide which truths are. We watched a version of that in 2025, when the FCC chairman said of Jimmy Kimmel, "We can do this the easy way or the hard way," and station owners with a merger in front of him pulled the show within hours. Nexstar says the two had nothing to do with each other.

But the First Amendment limits the government. It doesn't require a billionaire to pay anyone for a post. It doesn't require an algorithm to push a hoax to millions. Those are business decisions.

Nobody's arguing about whether a man can shout. The problem is the theater owners who wired the speakers, sold ads next to the scream, paid the shouter by the decibel, and then told the fire marshal to go home.

The verdict

From here on, this is opinion.

I've done this a long time. In July 2025, I watched Meta wipe out nearly two decades of my work in one day. So understand what I'm saying and what I'm not. I'm not asking anyone to silence anybody. The same companies that erased me for free are paying people to lie. I want them to stop writing the checks.

Here's the verdict after six parts: almost none of this is illegal. That's the scandal. Nobody had to break the law to build this. They only had to leave it unwritten. One vote in 2010. One bill in 2017 that never got a floor vote. One memo in 2025.

So I'll say this the only honest way I can, as my opinion. To me, these are treasonous acts that the laws and the courts haven't caught up to yet. Under the law as it's written today, none of this is treason, and I'm not calling any named person a traitor. But taking hidden money to turn Americans against each other is a betrayal of this country, whatever the statute books call it.

This is what we'll be remembered for. Either we let the days pass by, or we saw this for what it is: a new kind of war, a digital one, fought without a formal declaration. And we decided to fight back.

The lie about Abdul El-Sayed was never about a clearance. It was about telling you a Muslim from Michigan can't really be one of us, so if he won, it must be a trick. Springfield was never about pets. The curry line was never a joke. Each one was a sales pitch for the same thing: be afraid of your neighbor, and stay angry long enough for someone to get paid.

Then November happened

Here's the part the machine didn't plan for.

Michigan voters heard every bit of it. The middle name. The "jihadist" talk. The chant of "Deport!" aimed at a man born in Michigan. They elected him anyway.

The product didn't sell.

That's the best news in this whole series, and it's not a reason to relax. A machine that loses one election doesn't shut down. It retools. The fake clearance story showed up within a week. So we don't wait for them to get better at it. We take the factory apart while it's down.

The bill

Four lines. That's all it takes.

  1. If you were paid to post about a candidate, a ballot measure or a public official, say so on the post. Same as a shampoo ad.

  2. Say who paid. The real payer, not the agency in the middle.

  3. Both sides of the deal are responsible: the one who paid and the one who posted.

  4. No exceptions for foreign money. No exceptions for either party.

Not one of those lines bans a single word. They put a price tag on the product. Courts have upheld that kind of label more firmly than any other campaign rule.

And this is not a fantasy. Texas already did it, 7 to 0, on a Republican-run commission. California added fines this fall. Two members of Congress from Florida, Republican Anna Paulina Luna and Democrat Jared Moskowitz, have already filed a bill together to make foreign-paid creators register. If those two can sign the same piece of paper, so can a Legislature.

Florida's session starts in March. Congress changes hands Jan. 3. I'm calling it the Paid By Act. Call it whatever you want. File it.

The scoreboard

I'm not ending this series with a hope. I'm ending it with a list.

Starting today, FMNN will keep a public scoreboard: every member of Florida's Legislature and every member of our congressional delegation, both parties, and one question next to each name. Did they sponsor a bill that makes paid political posts say who paid? Yes or no, from the public record. No statements. No spin. A name and an answer.

And here's what you can hold me to, on this and every investigation after it:

  • Receipts. Every claim links to its source. Check me. Don't trust me.

  • Both directions. When the money comes from the left, I report it the same way.

  • Names, not vibes. Who paid, who owns it, who voted.

  • News and opinion kept apart. When it's my take, the page says so.

  • Corrections in the open. If I get it wrong, I fix it on the page and say what changed.

  • Nobody pays for a post on FMNN without a label on it. Ever.

Before you share

You're the last guard still on duty. Three questions, every time:

Who's the target? What's the source? Who gets paid if I'm angry?

They sell hate because it sells. In November, in Michigan, it didn't.

So stop buying. Then make them print the price tag.

Joseph J. Jackson is the founder of Florida Man News Network. This is the last part of a six-part series. The scoreboard starts now.

Sources

Parts 1 through 5 carry the full source lists for every figure in "The machine" and "The receipt." New in this part:

  1. Snopes: El-Sayed background check

  2. Lead Stories: El-Sayed did not fail a background check

  3. Diane Gruber Substack repost (shown for the record)

  4. Newsweek: Cruz on El-Sayed and the Intelligence Committee

  5. NBC News via NBC Washington: El-Sayed wins; Trump's attacks

  6. NBC News via NBC DFW: Trump's "jihadists" claims

  7. NBC News: Vance on Loomer; Springfield officials

  8. ABC News via 6abc: Loomer's Springfield memes; Greene response

  9. AP via KVIA: debate audience

  10. Washington Post: Loomer paid for political posts (Nov. 7, 2026)

  11. Decrypt: how X creator revenue sharing pays

  12. CNN via ABC17: Carr "easy way or the hard way"

  13. Variety: Nexstar denies FCC pressure

  14. Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S. 47 (1919); Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969)

  15. Scripps News: timeline of the Springfield pet rumor

  16. NBC News via NBC Washington: Springfield woman says she never meant to spark rumors

  17. WCPO / Springfield News-Sun: both women say they have no proof

  18. ABC News: Vance kept up claims after aide was told they were baseless

  19. CNN via ABC17: Springfield mayor confirms Vance staffer was told rumors were baseless

  20. Ohio Capital Journal via Daily Montanan: Vance spread rumors after staff was told they were false

  21. Axios: the Sept. 9 call

  22. PolitiFact: fact checks from Vance's Sept. 15, 2024 CNN interview ("create stories")

  23. CBS News: Trump calls El-Sayed a "Muslim Brotherhood Member"; no evidence

  24. Michigan Advance: Vance campaigns for Rogers, Oct. 27, 2026

Previous
Previous

Rain Settles In Over Tampa Bay Through Friday, and the Flooding Risk Shifts Inland

Next
Next

CNN: US Intel Says Iran Is Drawing Up Dirty-Bomb Plans for DC